Why Some Scientists Are Convinced That We Are Living Amidst a 6th Mass Extinction

Paleontologist thinks that in a few million years, future Earth inhabitants may puzzle over the extinction of humanity. They will find a horrible mess of black carbon polluted shale and wonder why we didn't do enough to prevent a mass extinction event that doomed us all.
Mass Extinction

Paleontologists widely accept that the Permian-Triassic extinction was one of the worst mass extinctions in Earth’s history. However, before the Permian-Triassic extinction, also known as the ‘Great Dying,’ there were at least two other significant extinction periods. Now scientists believe that humans are living through a sixth mass extinction.

We humans are not designed to be a planet on which the majority of species die out over the course of many generations as a result of our fossil fuel consumption and other factors. If we don’t choose to change our behavior, we will drive off the rest of the planet’s wildlife and other life forms. In the past, animals and plants have been driven to extinction by war, disease, over-hunting, and environmental factors. But we’re not looking at this as extinction but as a death sentence.

According to paleontologists, a mass extinction occurs when more than seventy-five percent of a given species becomes extinct in a very short time in geological terms, typically less than two million years. 


How is the current extinction process calculated?

The International Union for Conservation of Nature has a Red List, which monitors the conservation status of threatened species, and is commonly used to estimate the number of species that have gone extinct in the last several decades.

Extinct species Zoootheque MNHN n01
Extinct bird specimens by Marie-Lan Taÿ Pamart under CC BY 4.0

But the organization has only looked at a small number of known species, a small number of the total number of species on Earth. Even among species that have been studied, many are thought to have too little information.

Some scientists, such as Gerardo Ceballos, an ecologist, and conservation biologist of the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, think that only looking at extinction rates makes the current biodiversity crisis seem less serious. Extinction is just the last step in a long process of population decline. 


Species population decline

In 2017, Ceballos and his colleagues looked at IUCN data on 27,600 species of land-based vertebrates. They found alarming rates of population decline, even in species that still had a lot of individuals. 

Since 1900, more than 40 percent of species have shrunk by more than 80 percent. Of the 177 species for which detailed data were available at the time, all had lost at least a third of their original range. 

Other groups have also found that the numbers of many ocean and freshwater fish species are dropping at an alarming rate.


How were extinctions caused in the past?

Extinction events have been caused by asteroid impacts, environmental catastrophes, or the release of toxic chemicals that kill off a large number of species. 

Ordovician-Silurian Extinction: 440 million years ago there was the Ordovician-Silurian mass extinction. The Ordovician-Silurian mass extinction has been estimated to be responsible for the extinction of 85 percent of all species, including a significant number of invertebrates. Small marine organisms died out. Some scientists believe that shifts in the oceans’ chemical composition or general climate cooling were the root causes of the Ordovician-Silurian extinction crisis.

The history of the development of the Earth by Shutterstock.com

Devonian Extinction: 365 million years ago, in the late Devonian period, environmental changes were responsible for the extinction of approximately 70–80 percent of species. Some researchers in the field of biodiversity believe that the recent decline in species variety can be attributed more to a slowdown in the process of species divergence than to an increase in the rate of species mass extinction.


Permian-Triassic Extinction: 250 million years ago, there was the Permian-Triassic Extinction, also termed the “Great Dying.” This extinction was responsible for the demise of 95 percent of marine species and numerous amphibians and reptiles that lived on land. Many scientists blame volcanism.

Triassic-Jurassic Extinction: 210 million years ago, the end of the Triassic extinction event was responsible for the extinction of around 80 percent of all species on Earth. During this time, there were ammonites and crocodile ancestors. Some authorities attribute this extinction event to global warming.

Cretaceous-tertiary Extinction: 65 million years ago, the K-Pg extinction event occurred when an asteroid struck the Earth, which resulted in the death of all dinosaurs that were unable to fly. There is a theory among scholars that the crisis was made worse by the volcanic activity in India.


Most mass extinctions were caused by volcanic eruptions, and new species emerge

According to one theory, the four major extinction events that occurred in the past are supposed to have been brought on by climate shifts brought on by large volcanic eruptions. Between these major extinction events, there were minor extinctions and times when things were relatively stable. During these times, new species typically emerged to take the place of those that became extinct.

Scientists think that the next mass extinction level event will be caused by humans

Many scientists are concerned that a subsequent catastrophe of this magnitude is only around the corner. They believe that this time it will be caused by our species, which has just been around for a few hundred thousand years at the most. Even if we haven’t reached that point just yet, the rate at which species become extinct is speeding up, and there are increasingly more species on the verge of extinction. 

Our legacy

James Witts, a paleontologist and geologist doesn’t know if we’re quite at the point of a mass extinction yet but thinks that we’re definitely going in that direction. Witts thinks that when creatures millions of years from now find our geological legacy, they will find something that looks just as interesting as the K-Pg extinction event. He says, “It’ll probably be some horrible kind of black shale,… full of the carbon humans have put into the air and traces of nuclear tests and metals taken from the Earth to build the modern world”. In the worst case, Witt says, “fossil patterns could show mass deaths that were as big as the K-Pg extinction.” 

Ohio Shale Olentangy Shale disconformity Upper Devonian Highbanks Park Lewis Center Ohio USA 6
Ohio Shale-Olentangy by James St. John under CC BY 2.0

If scientists and paleontologists are to be believed, it looks like the extinction event that we are in the midst of is a result of human’s own doing from carbon and other pollution. Is removing carbon from the air the solution? There are solutions that can already remove 99% of carbon from the air, yet US Centre for International Environmental Law regards such technologies as a dangerous distraction. While NASA is putting in place asteroid defense strategies, the solutions for avoiding the next mass extinction may be much closer to home and within our power, or perhaps it is already too late.

Featured image credit: Mass Extinction by Shutterstock.com

Recent Posts

Follow Us